Bag of Onyx Coffee Lab whole bean coffee pulled from its box
Onyx Coffee Lab logo

Onyx Coffee Lab

  • Specialty coffee subscription
  • From $20.43

Onyx Coffee Lab is a specialty coffee roaster from Northwest Arkansas, founded in 2012, and one of the most respected names in American third wave coffee. Beyond its cafes, Onyx sells its coffee online with two kinds of subscriptions: Roaster’s Choice, which sends a different single origin coffee each time, and regular deliveries of its core blends like Southern Weather and Monarch.

Our take: Onyx is a subscription for people who already care about coffee, or want to. The roasts are light to medium and the single origins taste bright, fruity and very different from grocery store coffee. It is not cheap, and the subscription discount is small, but the quality and the transparency are top tier. If you like dark, smoky coffee, start with Monarch or look elsewhere.

Bag of Onyx Coffee Lab whole bean coffee pulled from its box
Roaster’s Choice ships a different single origin coffee every week

How the Onyx Coffee subscription works

There is no quiz and no monthly box. You pick a coffee on onyxcoffeelab.com, choose the bag size, then choose how often it should arrive: every 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 or 8 weeks. That flexibility is one of the best things about Onyx.

You have two kinds of subscriptions to choose from:

  • Roaster’s Choice: a different single origin coffee with every shipment, picked by the roasting team. Onyx calls it its most popular subscription by far.
  • A core coffee on repeat: the same blend or coffee every time, with 5% off the regular price.

Coffee is roasted to order Monday through Friday and ships within a day of roasting, so it arrives fresh. Roaster’s Choice ships on Mondays and Tuesdays. Other subscriptions process on the same weekday as your first order and ship within 1 to 2 business days.

Roaster’s Choice: a new coffee every week

Roaster’s Choice is the reason most people subscribe. Onyx changes the coffee every Monday and releases more than 50 single origins a year, so you will rarely get the same one twice. You do not choose the coffee and cannot swap it, but Onyx posts the upcoming lineup on the product page, with tasting notes for each week.

To give you an idea, recent picks included a natural process coffee from the Elshadai estate in Kenya (dark chocolate, melon, blackberry), a natural from Las Lajas in Costa Rica (cherry, milk chocolate, honey), and a honey process from Aponte Village in Colombia (Rainier cherry, butterscotch, green apple). Expect Ethiopia, Kenya, Colombia, Rwanda, Burundi and Central America to come up often.

Roaster’s Choice size Price per delivery
10 oz box $27
2 lbs $72
5 lbs $164

There is no subscription discount on Roaster’s Choice, which is sold only as a subscription. At $27 for 10 oz, it is premium pricing, though in line with other top single origin roasters.

Onyx Coffee Lab Southern Weather blend box
Southern Weather is the house blend and the easiest place to start

Core coffee subscriptions and prices

If you want the same coffee every time, subscribe to one of Onyx’s core coffees. Subscriptions take 5% off. Here are the 10 oz prices, the most common size:

Coffee One time Subscription Style
Southern Weather $21.50 $20.43 House blend, chocolate with some brightness
Monarch $21.50 $20.43 Darkest roast, great with milk
Cold Brew $21.50 $20.43 Core coffee
Geometry $22.50 $21.38 The espresso Onyx serves in its cafes
Eclipse $22.50 $21.38 Core coffee
Blend Cycle $23 $21.85 Core coffee
Tropical Weather $24.50 $23.28 Fruity, modern blend
Power Nap $24.50 $23.28 Core coffee
Decaf (Colombia Inzá San Antonio) $24.50 $23.28 Single origin decaf

Most core coffees also come in 2 lb and 5 lb bags, which are much cheaper per ounce. Southern Weather, for example, is $56.50 for 2 lbs or $53.68 on subscription. A 2 oz sample size ($6) is a cheap way to try a blend before you commit.

Onyx labels every coffee on a Traditional to Modern scale. Traditional means nutty, chocolatey and winey flavors. Modern means citrus, floral and fruit, and usually a lighter roast. Southern Weather sits in the middle, which is why it is the easiest place to start.

Onyx Coffee Lab Monarch blend box
Monarch is the darkest coffee Onyx roasts, built for espresso with milk

Shipping, grinding and freshness

Onyx offers free shipping on orders of $50 or more. Below that, shipping is added at checkout, so a single 10 oz box often pays shipping, while a 2 lb bag or two boxes clears the bar. Orders go out by USPS.

Single origin coffees ship as whole bean only. For online orders, Onyx can grind its core coffees: Southern Weather, Tropical Weather, Geometry, Monarch, Decaf, Cold Brew, Power Nap and Eclipse.

Once opened, a bag is at its best for about 30 days. Because Onyx roasts lighter than most, the coffee fades faster than a dark roast. Roll the bag down and keep it in its box, which is designed to work as a container. For 2 and 5 lb bags, use an airtight container.

Onyx Coffee Lab Tropical Weather blend box
Tropical Weather is the brighter, fruitier blend

Skipping, changing and canceling

Everything is managed from your Onyx account under Manage Subscription:

  • Skip a delivery: View Details, then Manage upcoming orders, then Skip Order. Recover Order undoes a skip.
  • Change the frequency: under Order frequency, select Change frequency.
  • Update address or card: View Details, then Address and shipping information, then Edit.
  • Cancel: View Details, then Cancel Subscription, and pick a reason.

There is no commitment, so you can cancel any time before the next order processes.

Onyx does not accept coffee returns, but if something is wrong with an order (damaged, lost, incorrect), email [email protected] with your order number and it will make it right, often with a replacement. Non coffee items can be returned within 30 days, unused, with a $5 restocking fee.

Barista brewing Onyx coffee as a pour over
Light roasts like these shine as a pour over

Is Onyx Coffee worth it?

For coffee lovers, yes. Onyx is one of the most respected roasters in the country, its cafe program was a 2026 James Beard Awards finalist for Outstanding Bar, and the single origins are genuinely special. The 1 to 8 week cadence is more flexible than most coffee clubs, and canceling takes a minute.

It is less convincing on value. The 5% subscription discount is small, Roaster’s Choice has no discount at all, and you pay shipping under $50. And if you love dark, bold coffee, most of the lineup will taste too bright for you.

Pros

  • Excellent, very fresh light and medium roasts
  • Roaster’s Choice brings a new single origin almost every week
  • Deliveries every 1 to 8 weeks, skip or cancel online
  • Price paid to farmers published on every coffee
  • Certified B Corporation

Cons

  • Pricey, with a small 5% subscription discount
  • Shipping charged on orders under $50
  • Single origins are whole bean only
  • Few options for dark roast fans
Onyx Coffee Lab Colombia single origin box next to a pour over brewer
Each 10 oz box doubles as a storage container once opened

Onyx vs other coffee subscriptions

If you like the idea of a different coffee every time but want more help choosing, Trade sends coffee from many roasters based on a taste quiz. Atlas Coffee Club does a coffee from a new country every month, with lower prices and less of a specialty edge. Among single roasters, Stumptown and Blue Bottle are the closest matches: both have rotating single origin subscriptions, and both are easier to find in stores. Driftaway and Bean Box are good for exploring different roasters.

If you want stronger, darker coffee, Death Wish Coffee is the opposite of Onyx in style, and Javvy covers protein coffee and concentrates. See all our coffee subscriptions.

Onyx gift subscriptions

Onyx gift subscriptions send one 10 oz box every 4 weeks for 3, 6 or 12 months, with shipping included. A 3 month gift starts at $65 for Southern Weather, $66 for Monarch, $69 for the (PRODUCT)RED coffee, $72 for Tropical Weather and $85 for Roaster’s Choice. The first box ships right after you order, so check out with the recipient’s address.

Onyx Coffee Lab (PRODUCT)RED coffee box
The (PRODUCT)RED coffee is one of the gift subscription options

Every holiday season, Onyx also sells an advent calendar with 24 days of coffee ($199 for the 2026 edition). It is a one time purchase, not part of a subscription, and you need to order by mid November to get it by December 1.

Onyx Coffee Lab advent calendar box with a pour over set
The yearly advent calendar is sold separately from subscriptions

Onyx Coffee Lab cafes

A lot of people search for Onyx because of its cafes. They are all in Northwest Arkansas, with locations in Rogers (the headquarters), Bentonville, Fayetteville, Springdale and at The Momentary, plus The Preserve. Each cafe has its own menu, with pastries and sandwiches from the in-house bakery. Coffee for the cafes and for online orders is roasted to order the same way.

Inside the Onyx Coffee Lab Rogers HQ cafe in Arkansas
Onyx roasts and runs its cafes in Northwest Arkansas

Onyx customer service

The FAQ and Help Center on onyxcoffeelab.com cover subscriptions, shipping and returns. For order problems, email [email protected] with your name and order number, or use the chat, open Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM Central time.

Frequently asked questions

Onyx Coffee Lab: your questions answered

Does Onyx Coffee have a subscription?

Yes. You can subscribe to Roaster’s Choice, a different single origin coffee each delivery, or to any core coffee like Southern Weather, Monarch, Geometry or Tropical Weather. You pick the bag size and a delivery every 1 to 8 weeks.

How much is the Onyx Coffee subscription?

Roaster’s Choice costs $27 for a 10 oz box, $72 for 2 lbs and $164 for 5 lbs per delivery. Core coffees are 5% off on subscription, so a 10 oz box of Southern Weather drops from $21.50 to about $20.43. Shipping is free on orders of $50 or more.

Can I cancel my Onyx subscription anytime?

Yes. Log in, select Manage Subscription, open the subscription with View Details, then click Cancel Subscription and pick a reason. There is no minimum number of orders.

How do I skip an Onyx delivery?

In your account, go to Manage Subscription, then View Details, then Manage upcoming orders, and click Skip Order next to the shipment. You can undo it with Recover Order. You can also change the frequency in the same place.

When does Onyx ship subscriptions?

Roaster’s Choice ships on Mondays and Tuesdays. Other subscriptions process on the same weekday as your first order. Coffee is roasted to order Monday through Friday and leaves within a day of roasting.

Does Onyx grind coffee for subscriptions?

Single origins ship as whole bean. Onyx can grind its core coffees for online orders: Southern Weather, Tropical Weather, Geometry, Monarch, Decaf, Cold Brew, Power Nap and Eclipse.

Is there an Onyx Coffee discount code?

Onyx shares discount codes and promotions with its email list, so signing up is the best way to get one. Core coffee subscriptions also take 5% off automatically, and shipping is free from $50.

Is Onyx Coffee fair trade?

Onyx does not buy Fair Trade certified coffee. It says it always pays at least double the Fair Trade price, often 3 to 5 times more, and publishes what it paid on each coffee page. Onyx is a Certified B Corporation.

Where are Onyx Coffee Lab cafes?

All Onyx cafes are in Northwest Arkansas, including Rogers (the HQ), Bentonville, Fayetteville and Springdale. The online shop ships the same coffee nationwide.

Bag of Onyx Coffee Lab whole bean coffee pulled from its box
Onyx Coffee Lab logo

Onyx Coffee Lab

  • Specialty coffee subscription
  • From $20.43

Similar Boxes

Questions & reviews

Have a question about this box?

Share a question, opinion or experience. Our team reads every message and will reply.

Start the conversation

Your email is never displayed. First-time contributions are reviewed before publication.

Onyx Coffee Lab logo

Onyx Coffee Lab

  • Specialty coffee subscription
  • From $20.43