Costco, the warehouse club best known for its $4.99 rotisserie chicken, is now selling a Captain America shield signed by 17 Avengers actors, including Robert Downey Jr., Chris Evans and Chris Hemsworth, for $15,999.99. The online-only listing, labeled a “Special Event” and “limited time offer, while supplies last,” says each actor also wrote their character name next to their signature. The twist: Fanatics, the company that authenticates the shield, sells its own 17-signature Captain America shield for $11,999.99, exactly $4,000 less, though its listing does not mention character names. Prices checked on Costco.com and Fanatics.com on November 19, 2026.

What Costco Is Selling
- Product: The Avengers Cast Autographed Captain America Shield, “Signed and Inscribed by 17 Actors” (Costco item 2005746, brand listed as Fanatics).
- Price: $15,999.99, online only, with UPS Ground shipping included.
- Signed by: Robert Downey Jr., Chris Evans, Chris Hemsworth, Chris Pratt, Benedict Cumberbatch, Paul Rudd, Paul Bettany, Josh Brolin, Dave Bautista, Zoe Saldana, Don Cheadle, Michael Douglas, Elizabeth Olsen, Sebastian Stan, Brie Larson, Jeremy Renner and Samuel L. Jackson.
- The extra touch: “Each Actor / Actress has inscribed their character name next to their signature,” according to Costco. On the listing photo you can read “Captain America” in the center star, plus “Star-Lord,” “Vision,” “Iron Man,” “Winter Soldier” and “Scarlet Witch” around the rim.
- Size: a life-size replica, 24 inches in diameter.
- Authentication: each shield is individually numbered and carries a tamper-evident hologram from Fanatics’ authentication program.
- Fine print: “Signatures May Vary,” so the shield you receive may not look exactly like the photo.
How Costco Shoppers Found It
The listing surfaced on Thursday, November 19, when a member posted it on Reddit’s r/Costco forum with a one-line verdict: “Costco really be selling anything.” The thread passed 400 upvotes within hours. Some members called it “a bargain for a Marvel fan,” others wrote that “no way that is worth $16,000,” and one asked the only question that matters at Costco: “Returnable?”
Another commenter quickly linked the Fanatics version of the shield, which is where the price gap shows up.
The Math: Costco vs. Fanatics

- Costco: $15,999.99 for 17 signatures with character names, or about $941 per autograph.
- Fanatics: $11,999.99 for “17 Signatures including Chris Evans, Robert Downey Jr. & Chris Hemsworth,” listed in stock and shipping within one business day, or about $706 per autograph.
- The gap: $4,000, or 33% more at Costco. If the character names are the only difference, that is about $235 per handwritten name.
The Fanatics listing names only three of its 17 signers and does not mention character inscriptions, and its photo shows plain signatures. We could not confirm that both shields carry the exact same 17 names.
Why It Matters
Costco.com already sells signed memorabilia: the same page suggests framed jerseys signed by Larry Bird, John Elway, Allen Iverson or John Stockton for $399.99 to $599.99, and a Chevy Chase Christmas Vacation poster for $189.99. But a five-figure Marvel shield is a different league, and it shows how far the big-box holiday catalog now stretches. Costco’s last holiday story on our site was a much humbler $99.99 hot cocoa advent calendar.
Pop culture collectibles are having a moment at every price point, from a $250 Rolling Stones lava lamp limited to 1,000 pieces to the LEGO Marvel advent calendar that sold out this month.
Our Take
We haven’t seen this shield in person. Getting 17 MCU stars on one prop is genuinely rare, and the character names make it a better display piece than a wall of scribbles. Buying through Costco also means one familiar seller, shipping included and the club’s usual satisfaction policy, though Costco notes that certain items have return limits, so check before you order. But the same brand’s own 17-signature shield costs $4,000 less, and “Signatures May Vary” means you are not buying the exact shield in the photo.
Best for: serious Marvel collectors who want the character names and like the idea of buying a $16,000 shield in the same order as their paper towels.
Skip it if: you only want the 17 autographs: Fanatics lists a version for $11,999.99.
Price and Availability: The Essentials
- Price: $15,999.99 on Costco.com (UPS Ground shipping included).
- Where: Costco.com only (“Online Only”), not in warehouses.
- Delivery: about 5 to 7 business days; not available to Alaska, Hawaii or Puerto Rico.
- Availability: “limited time offer, while supplies last”; listed as available on November 19, 2026, with no reviews yet.
- Alternative: Fanatics’ 17-signature shield, $11,999.99.
- Not confirmed: how many shields Costco has, the edition size, how and where the actors signed them, and whether Costco’s standard return policy applies to this item.
Source: Costco.com product page; Fanatics.com product page; r/Costco thread, November 19, 2026.





Questions & reviews
Have a question about this box?
Share a question, opinion or experience. Our team reads every message and will reply.