John Oliver’s feud with Buc-ee’s now comes with a Christmas tree decoration. Last Week Tonight’s Buc-Off store now sells a $19.95 resin ornament of Mr. Nutterbutter, the show’s squirrel mascot, wearing a Buc-Off trucker cap and a red Buc-Off T-shirt. It sits next to two new holiday sweatshirts at $39.95 each. Oliver announced the holiday drop on the show’s season finale on Sunday, November 15, and told viewers to fill stockings with “a gift made entirely out of spite.” The store says proceeds go to Hunger Free America. As of November 17, 2026, the ornament page lists it as in stock, limited to one per customer.

What’s in the Buc-Off Holiday Drop
- Mr. Nutterbutter ornament, $19.95: a 3D resin ornament about 3.5 inches tall, with a gold hanging cord. The squirrel stands hands on hips in a white-and-black Buc-Off cap and a red Buc-Off tee. Limit 1 per customer.
- Holiday Sweatshirt, $39.95: a Bella+Canvas unisex sponge fleece, drop-shoulder sweatshirt in Holiday Red or Holiday Green, with an ugly-sweater-style pattern around the Buc-Off logo. Limit 1 per color.
- Shipping: everything is made to order. The store says the ornament ships within 3 weeks and the sweatshirt within 2 weeks of the order (as of November 15).
- All sales are final: no returns, refunds, size exchanges or cancellations.

The rest of the Buc-Off store is still open too, from a $14.95 knit beanie and a $15.95 ceramic mug to $32.95 flannel pajama pants, $16.95 boxer briefs and a $17.95 baby onesie. A line at the bottom of the site reads: “The merchandise for sale on this website is not authorized by or affiliated with Buc-ee’s.”
Why a Squirrel Is Mocking a Beaver
Oliver went after Buc-ee’s on Last Week Tonight this summer over the Texas travel-center chain’s habit of taking smaller businesses to court over animal mascots it says copy its cartoon beaver. The show answered with its own deliberately provocative logo, Mr. Nutterbutter in a Buc-ee’s-style circle, and opened Buc-Off.com.
Then Buc-ee’s sued Beaver’s Mini Mart, a small convenience store in Beavercreek, Ohio. The original federal complaint was filed on July 28 and an amended one followed on October 20, according to WKEF in Dayton. Oliver pledged to keep his store open until the company dropped the case. On Sunday’s finale he said it hadn’t: “If Buc-ee’s isn’t going to stop their lawsuits, we are not gonna close our store either.” He also said the Buc-Off merch had raised more than $600,000 for Hunger Free America so far, as reported by late-night news site LateNighter.
The timing is sharp. On November 10, a federal judge ordered Buc-ee’s to show cause why its case against Beaver’s Mini Mart should not be dismissed, because the store had apparently not been served with the complaint within the 90 days federal rules allow. Buc-ee’s had until today, November 17, to respond. A dismissal on those grounds would be procedural, not a ruling on the trademark claim, and Buc-ee’s could refile.
The Math
- One ornament plus one sweatshirt: $59.90 before shipping and tax.
- The ornament costs the same as the store’s $19.95 pom beanie, and $5 less than the $24.95 T-shirt.
- Purchase limits cap each customer at 1 ornament and 2 sweatshirts (1 red, 1 green).
Why It Matters
Most holiday merch this year is a brand selling its own fans a joke about itself, like Chipotle’s hoodie with a hidden burrito pocket or King’s Hawaiian’s sweet-roll slippers. Buc-Off is the reverse: a TV show selling a joke about somebody else’s brand, with the money going to charity and an active federal lawsuit as the backdrop. A squirrel on your tree is a small, cheap way to pick a side.
Our Take
We haven’t held the ornament. From the store photos it looks like a solid little resin figure rather than a flat printed disc, and at $19.95 it is the cheapest way into the feud that is actually festive. The sweatshirts are fun, but they are a standard blank with a print, and final-sale sizing on a made-to-order item is a gamble. The bigger catch is timing: a 3-week shipping window means an ornament ordered today may not ship until around December 8. Don’t wait if it’s meant for the tree.
Best for: Last Week Tonight fans, anyone from Beavercreek, and people who want a gag gift where the money goes to a hunger charity.
Skip it if: you’re a loyal Buc-ee’s regular, or you need guaranteed delivery before a specific date.
Price and Availability: The Essentials
- Ornament: $19.95, 3D resin, about 3.5 in. tall, limit 1 per customer.
- Holiday Sweatshirt: $39.95, Holiday Red or Holiday Green, limit 1 per color.
- Where: only at Buc-Off.com, the official Last Week Tonight store. Look-alike “Buc Off” sites exist; the official one says it is not affiliated with Buc-ee’s.
- Shipping: made to order; ornament within 3 weeks, sweatshirt within 2 weeks (store notice dated November 15).
- Proceeds: go to Hunger Free America, per the store.
- Not confirmed: how many ornaments will be made, how long the holiday items stay on sale, shipping costs, and the $600,000 total, which we have not seen in an official statement from the show or the charity.
Source: Buc-Off ornament page, Buc-Off Holiday Sweatshirt page, Buc-Off.com (all checked November 17, 2026); Last Week Tonight season finale (HBO, November 15, 2026), quotes as reported by LateNighter; court order details from WKEF / Local 12.





Questions & reviews
Have a question about this box?
Share a question, opinion or experience. Our team reads every message and will reply.