Menlo Club is the men’s clothing subscription formerly known as Five Four Club. Each month you get a package of two to three pieces picked by the Menlo stylists, mostly from the group’s own labels: Five Four for everyday menswear, New Republic for shoes, and Grand AC for athleisure.
You take a short style quiz, pick your sizes, and the club builds your boxes around that profile. The idea is that every package matches what you already received, so after a few months you have a wardrobe that mixes and matches without much thought.

Menlo Club plans and prices
| Plan | Price | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly | $60 a month | 2 to 3 pieces every month |
| Seasonal | $60 per box | 2 to 3 pieces every three months (March, June, September, December) |
| Shipping | Free in the contiguous US | $7 extra to Alaska and Hawaii, $25 to Canada, $30 to the UK |
| Member perk | Included | Up to 25% off the Menlo House online store |
What’s in a Menlo Club package
Over a year, the club says members get New Republic footwear in two months, Grand AC athleisure in two more, and Five Four contemporary pieces the rest of the time. Expect things like:
- Button-up shirts, polos, and tees
- Chinos, joggers, and denim
- Sweaters, overshirts, and light jackets in cooler months
- Sneakers or casual shoes in the footwear months
Quality is solid mall-plus menswear rather than designer. The styling is safe and wearable: neutral colors, slim but not skinny fits, and pieces you can wear to the office on a casual day.


Monthly or seasonal?
Both plans cost $60 per package, so the difference is frequency. Monthly gets you 12 packages a year and builds a wardrobe fast. Seasonal sends four packages a year and adds some choice: seasonal members can swap their package for other curated options or a $75 New Republic gift card.
If you mainly want a few new pieces each season, seasonal is the smarter plan. Monthly is for guys who genuinely want to outsource most of their clothes shopping.

How to cancel or pause Menlo Club
You can cancel from the cancellation form in your member dashboard, by phone, or by live chat. The key date is the 14th: cancel or pause before the 14th of the month or you will be charged for the next package on the 15th. You can pause for up to three months at a time.
There are no returns on club packages and no refunds. Size exchanges are allowed within 30 days if the item is unworn.

Is Menlo Club worth it?
For guys who hate shopping and dress casual, yes. You get a steady flow of wearable basics at a fair price and the pieces really do pair well together. If you are particular about colors and brands, or you need to send things back, a try-before-you-buy service fits you better.
Pros
- $60 for two or three pieces is good value per item
- Packages are designed to work together over time
- Free shipping and size exchanges
- Seasonal plan for a slower pace
- Member discount on the Menlo House store
Cons
- No choice over items on the monthly plan
- No returns, only size exchanges
- Strict cancel deadline on the 14th
- Mostly house brands
Best alternatives to Menlo Club
See all men’s fashion subscription boxes and more subscription boxes for men.
- Menlo Club vs Stitch Fix Men: Stitch Fix Men lets you try pieces from many brands at home and return what you do not want. More choice, but no flat price.
- Menlo Club vs Bespoke Post: Bespoke Post focuses on curated gear and accessories rather than clothes, with full control over each box.
- Menlo Club vs Dive Bar Shirt Club: Dive Bar Shirt Club sends one fun tee from a real American bar each month. Cheaper and more playful, but only T-shirts.
- Menlo Club vs Society Socks: Society Socks is the low-cost way to add something new to your outfit every month.
Menlo Club FAQ
How much is Menlo Club?
$60 a month for the monthly plan, or $60 every three months for the seasonal plan, plus tax. Shipping is free in the contiguous US.
Is there a Menlo Club promo code?
The club usually shows a $10 off first month offer on its join page, applied at checkout. Only one promo or referral code can be used at sign up.
How do I cancel Menlo Club?
Use the cancellation form in your member dashboard, call member experience, or use live chat. Do it before the 14th of the month to avoid the next charge.
Is Menlo Club the same as Five Four Club?
Yes. Five Four Club was renamed Menlo Club, and it is still run by the Five Four Group.

Ordered this for my boyfriend. The first month was OK for $30. Great pair of dark jeans and a button up shirt. The shirt was made of really cheap cotton though. The button-up immediately went wrinkly like crumpled paper after being put through the dryer…. Not worth wearing again, it was like an $8 shirt at most.
The 2nd month… They sent 2 t-shirts and 1 pullover sweater worth about $22 total at most. Trying to cancel but they won’t let you unless you call in… And the wait times are like over an HOUR.
This subscription company is EVIL and basically sells reproduced shit from China at 3x markup. I’ve never experienced a subscription that was so difficult to cancel.
DO NOT BUY. YOU ARE WARNED.
I had Five Four for about 6 months. They were ok, mostly hit or miss and definitely not for bigger guys. A few times the shipping took forever and I got two sets back to back because the first one never made it in time. The quality of the clothing is meh and many times buttons and stitching are weak. Button down shirts tend to be thin fabric that’s hard to keep ironed. A few sweaters I got were pretty cool, but too small so useless. Overall the box is ok if you have no idea what to wear and can fix their size, probably for Medium to Large people.
I didn’t deal much with customer service but when I did they were quick to answer on e-mail. The packaging is just a bag with the clothing. Nothing fancy, does the job. The price versus the quality is meh. Honestly if you have $60 you can hit Kohl’s and get similar items for the price. They claim the box is $120ish but in the end they control the manufacturing from top to bottom and the quality is not good enough to represent $120 in my opinion.
Overall the boxes were good to guide towards a style I wanted and then I just cancelled and went to Kohl’s from then on. Hope this helps.
Okay, so I signed up with a coupon and got $15 off.
They ask you some questions about your style and they offer three choices. Business Casual, T-Shirt and Jeans and Dress to Impress. What they don’t tell you is the last category is actually a blending of the first two. So I picked the last and got two t-shirt and a hoodie. I was underwhelmed and told customer service and what was delivered would impress no one. They have a policy of no returns unless you are adjusting for sizing. Well as luck would have it the clothes fit me perfectly (XXL) and since my brother has the same body type and a birthday that he should enjoy the hoodie and one t-shirt.
So I had them change my style profile to Business Casual and I told them no more hoodies ever!
All I can do is wait until next month and see what that brings.
Time will tell.
So overall they did not do great, but not badly either. Is it value for what you are spending? Possibly? They included an invoice that described the pricing. They charged $38 for each t-shirt and $60 for the hoodie. So the box was worth (in their minds) $136 plus $10 shipping. But since I’m a club member the shipping charge was waived. Also if I want to go to their website and purchase anything I will get a discount. Was the T-shirt that I kept worth it? Yep!
I look forward to reading your review
ddc